July 23, 2017


Posted in Uncategorized at 11:18 pm by yisraelmedad


Published as

Let My People Pray At The Temple Mount — It Will Teach Palestinians A Lesson at The Forward

By Yisrael Medad

This past Wednesday I again ascended to the Temple Mount, as I have done many scores of times, and, following the police security check, was permitted to enter the compound Muslims call the Haram A-Sharif, the Noble Sanctuary. The precincts were empty, totally so. I did not see more than a half-dozen Muslims there except for eight tourists who appeared to originate from an Asian country. Despite this dearth, there were more policemen than usual and they appeared more heavily armed and quite tense.

That we were allowed in was a minor miracle as visits by Jews had been halted during the morning window for non-Muslims to be present. Someone had opened a siddur (prayer book), it seems, an act which is proscribed (there actually is a list of some twenty actions a Jew, or a Christian, for that matter, cannot do. That includes murmuring, moving ones lips as if reciting, prostration or shaking in a ritual fashion (shuckling). That ban of such activities is the practical translation of what is known as the status quo.

And this week’s developments, with Muslims refusing to enter and conducting prayer assemblies outside, is all because of a perceived change in that status quo. Who would have thought that a metal detector was such a powerful instrument?


A fortnight after the Six-Days War, Moshe Dayan, then Defense Minister, awarded to the Waqf Islamic Religious Trust the internal administration of the Temple Mount and agreed to a status quo arrangement that no Jews would be permitted to pray therein.  At a meeting on October 24, 2015, Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu gave Jordan’s King Abdallah II and then US Secretary of State John Kerry, this assurance:

Israel re-affirms…the status quo of the Temple Mount, in word and in practice. Israel will continue to enforce its longstanding policy: Muslims pray on the Temple Mount; non-Muslims visit the Temple Mount.”

In doing so, Netanyahu continued Israel’s governments’ 50-year commitment, upheld numerous times by the country’s High Court for Justice, that, more than anything else, has contributed to the delegimitization of the standing of Jews at the site most sacred to, and historically and nationally, the most central location of, the Jewish nation. And we are angry and upset at UNESCO.

If anyone was cheering on the Women of the Wall (WOW), it was me. A religious location. A violent repression. An obscurantist adversary. And an issue of freedom of worship. All the ingredients were present but when pressed on the obvious parallel between the rights of WOW and the Temple Mount, MK Tamar Zandberg (Meretz) declared in 2013 that while every person of any religion has the right to pray in the places he or she considers holy, “Jews will only be able to pray in the places holy to them after the occupation ends and Jerusalem is [re]divided”.

Not only does Israeli law protect the right of free access and prayer, well, except for Jews at the Temple Mount, but the Israel-Jordan Peace Treaty’s Article 9 stipulates:

Each Party will provide freedom of access to places of religious and historical significance…The Parties will act together to promote interfaith relations among the three monotheistic religions, with the aim of working towards religious understanding…freedom of religious worship, and tolerance…”

So why then did Jordan’s Minister of Awqaf and Islamic Affairs Wael Arabiyat on Saturday hold Israeli authorities “responsible for the mounting tension and violence in the holy compound” when it was three Arab terrorists who had murdered two Israeli policemen? Were his words in line with the peace treaty’s goals?


I am not sure that those metal detectors will be in place by the time this is published but it would be a tragic error if Israel withdraws and retreats, not from any territory but simply from a logical decision based on security needs: for persons of all faiths on the Temple Mount, including tourists.

The Palestinian Authority Waqf forced Jordan to abandon the idea of 24-hour surveillance cameras, the King’s idea (although he had opposed it in 2013!) which Secretary Kerry had promoted enthusiastically and even Mahmoud Abbas didn’t oppose, at first. Those cameras perhaps could have prevented last week’s terror attack. The Palestine Arabs, once again, as in 1937 with the Peel Partition, in 1947’s UN  Partition Plan, Menachem Begin’s 1977 Autonomy idea, the 2000 Camp David II and 2008’s left behind map of Ehud Olmert, willingly sabotage any attempt to inject rationality and equity into the Arab conflict with Israel and Zionism.  They first and foremost threaten violence to achieve their political goals as since 1920’s Pesach Riot, the Waqf officials now are calling for mass prayers outside the compound and I presume that riots are their goal.

In 1929, they fabricated a Temple Mount “takeover” that led to 135 Jews killed and the slaughter in Hebron. Currently, they falsely promote the lie that “Al-Aqsa is in Danger”. Their unwillingness to acknowledge Jewish nationalism, their diplomatic rejectionism and their preference for violence as a strategic tool is what is wrong, not Jews seeking basic civil liberties.  We seek no less than Muslims themselves champion as, for example, their wish to pray at Cordoba’s Cathedral although we desire to obtain our rights through peaceful means.

If their posturing forces Israel to yield, there’ll be no end to the pressures at every turn.  Arabs need be taught, as patronizing as this may sound, that they are subject to the same rules as everybody else. To let the Arabs believe we are not truly convinced of our rights here in Jerusalem and at the Temple Mount will but compound Dayan’s error in 1967 which set the tone for their diplomacy since then, with the Temple Mount but a microcosm of the greater conflict.


Yisrael Medad, Secretary of El Har Hashem (To the Mount of the Lord), is a member of the Temple Mount Activists Coordinating Committee


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: